Author Topic: This Chinese Claims "Kinh" are actually rebellious "Han"  (Read 1713 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Online Rude Boy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 522
  • Karma: +2/-1
  • Gender: Male
  • Cờ lờ mờ vờ, cờ lờ vờ
    • Austroasiatic Phenotypes
Re: This Chinese Claims "Kinh" are actually rebellious "Han"
« Reply #80 on: May 13, 2019, 05:57:33 PM »
Oh god, B denoted in the pie chart from Kinh is mostly B4 they talked about, not B5 + B4 found high frequencies among Thai/Tai/Cham. There are B5 among Vietnamese, those found low frequencies.

Post me the link of Cham they studied, let me see what they study. Judging from pie chart I can't tell much of the genetic of Cham but I certain B4 Vietnamese carry does not come from Cham.

Ok now i have a clear understanding of what halopgroup B in the paper you cited is. Hmong's most frequent B subhaplogroup is B4 and so the B they refer to in the paper that you cited is mostly B4 , otherwise they would not have coloured B haplopgroup all blue in the pie charts.

Here is the paper. It is mostly about genetic makeup of Cham people

I'm still interested in other sub-haplogroup like B5 though. I believe B5 does have some contribution in Southern Vietnamese (not Central Vietnamese) because there are few Viets who cluster with Khmer in an autosomal study of Vietnamese in Saigon. The paper you cited gives people details about the distribution of only 3 haplogroups: M7, B4, F1 in Vietnamese population. 

So final conclusion:

more M7 = more Vietic (Tho, Chut)
more F1 = more Tai (Tay, Dai)
more B4 = more Hmong (Miao)

Offline AnNamMit

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
  • Karma: +4/-1
Re: This Chinese Claims "Kinh" are actually rebellious "Han"
« Reply #81 on: May 15, 2019, 07:47:15 PM »
I read the article you posted. Basically, what it said is Cham's mtDNA is just like other SEA ethnic groups with the composition of M7,B,F,R9. Almost all SEA ethnic groups have those haplogroups predominant.

Cham maternal lineage isn't much different from Vietnamese. The difference is the paternal lineage (Y-DNA) while Cham has South Asian, Vietnamese has genetic from people came from which is now China.

In order to understand, the wholely different you need to understand the other half of the story, the Y-DNA.

The Vietnamese Y-DNA as stated in the paper has O-M7 which found high frequency than Cham. The Kinh Vietnamese Y-DNA is also admixture and different in Northern, Central and Southern. If you want to know which group carry high frequency O-M7 looks for Wiki link below (wiki is not always accurate, make sure verify the wiki references)

Quotes from the article
Male South Asians contributeto the genetic makeup of Chams, but not South Asian females.

the origin of the Chams is mainly a result of admixture betweenthe Austronesian immigrants from ISEA with the indigenouspopulations (most likely, Mon-Khmers) in MSEA

The conclusion, SEA was populated by indigenous aboriginal natives then South Asian, Tai, Hmong, and other ethnics in China came after. The different among Thai, Viet, Han, Cham is the Y-DNA while mtDNA are similar with M7, B, R9, F predominant.

Online Rude Boy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 522
  • Karma: +2/-1
  • Gender: Male
  • Cờ lờ mờ vờ, cờ lờ vờ
    • Austroasiatic Phenotypes
Re: This Chinese Claims "Kinh" are actually rebellious "Han"
« Reply #82 on: May 17, 2019, 01:57:57 AM »
You are funny if Saigon Vietnamese are definitely not representative of Southern Viet and Hue / Da Nang Vietnamese may not represent Central Vietnamese then which place should represent them? The Hanoi? Do you have any idea why the cities are picked for a genetic test and not elsewhere? Because of the big diversity where many ethnic groups live to represent the people of the region. The city also a place where the elite group lives. You can't just go to Tra Vinh and pick samples DNA there because of the concentration of single ethnic Khmer, would be incorrect to use the sample of Khmer to represent the region, you get the idea though?
So would you think that Bangkok Thais represent average Thais in Central Thailand? City has great diversity but its also where Sinitic admixture is the most prevalent.

Like in Malaysia you have many more Chinese living in cities like Kualar Lumpur than in the rural areas dominated by native Malays. Southern Vietnam has greater diversity than what that pie chart said about Saigon Vietnamese mtDNA. Heck even Northern Vietnam has Mon-Khmer looking folks in the Northwest but they are largely left out in any genetic study of Vietnamese people.

Online Rude Boy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 522
  • Karma: +2/-1
  • Gender: Male
  • Cờ lờ mờ vờ, cờ lờ vờ
    • Austroasiatic Phenotypes
Re: This Chinese Claims "Kinh" are actually rebellious "Han"
« Reply #83 on: May 17, 2019, 02:54:16 PM »
Worse still would be if everyone just got slaughtered and were just replaced wholesale.  Obviously wars of these kind don't happen anymore so it can only be hypothesized at what really happened.
Population doesn't get replaced wholesale, at worst their number only get reduced. When a group loses a war to another, they either stay and mix or they migrate and mix. Or both.


* Recent Posts

Why didn't Vietnamese lose national identity after 1000 yrs of Chinese Ocupation by Rude Boy
[Today at 07:42:00 AM]

Is it racist to think that Filipinos cannot self actualize to Kinh? by
[Today at 12:54:27 AM]

China looks to hostile world, and USA wants containment countries rich! by
[Today at 12:42:29 AM]

Cuong Dola´s Girlfriends by
[Today at 12:37:24 AM]

Xi Jinping´s daughter studied at Harvard because Xi doesn´t trust China by
[Today at 12:34:25 AM]

What do Vietnamese do with good cuts of steak? by
[Today at 12:29:50 AM]

Collecting Vietnamese Art with Dr. Tuan Pham by
[Today at 12:25:40 AM]

ASEAN was a NATO organizaton founded to resist communist Vietnam´s expansion by
[Today at 12:24:23 AM]

Why do Chinese like jellyfish so much? by CognacXO
[Yesterday at 11:47:46 PM]

Tonkin Campaign 1883: First coalition race war between Asians and Europeans by CognacXO
[Yesterday at 11:12:53 PM]

This celebrity has a punchable face by Lavender
[Yesterday at 07:37:43 PM]

Stable housing drives productivity by convoy
[Yesterday at 04:06:39 PM]

Tanka People of Baiyue, whose ancestors fought Han, now eager to be Han by Rude Boy
[Yesterday at 03:16:21 PM]

Geopolitical history of Northern Vietnam by
[Yesterday at 02:34:07 PM]

Why so many Vietnamese movie directors gay? by
[Yesterday at 02:16:33 PM]

Our minorities are absorbing Kinh perversion by
[Yesterday at 01:44:57 PM]

OMG Viet Girls Gone Wild: Ao Dai Edition by Rude Boy
[Yesterday at 01:31:33 PM]

We were Chinese before we became Vietnamese by Rude Boy
[Yesterday at 12:57:40 PM]

Life in Southwest Vietnam by CognacXO
[Yesterday at 11:28:02 AM]

Did Cao Cao look Korean or Vietnamese? by ChinaWantsTheEntireMultiverse
[Yesterday at 09:13:27 AM]

some hillbilly said I sounded like a country hick by gaden
[Yesterday at 09:10:18 AM]

Vietnam Republic Airborne Unit (shrimpers) vs KKK 1981 by gaden
[Yesterday at 08:55:29 AM]

Foods beverage combinations of priming and then follow up by gaden
[Yesterday at 08:42:29 AM]

Vietnamese Lingo by gaden
[Yesterday at 08:36:10 AM]

Director of "The Third Wife" a Viet woman born in Saigon named "ASH MAYFAIR" WTF by gaden
[Yesterday at 08:25:50 AM]

* News Feeds